Composite Failure Criteria Comparison Reference
A quick reference comparing maximum stress, maximum strain, Tsai-Hill, Tsai-Wu, Hashin, Puck and LaRC criteria — mode ID, interaction, data needs.
Comparison
| Criterion | Mode ID | Interaction | Data Needed | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum stress | Yes (component) | No | Basic strengths | Simple screening |
| Maximum strain | Yes (component) | No | Ultimate strains | Strain-based design |
| Tsai-Hill | No | Yes | Basic strengths | Overall screening |
| Tsai-Wu | No | Yes | Basic strengths | Overall screening |
| Hashin | Yes (fibre/matrix) | Yes | Basic strengths | Progressive damage |
| Puck | Yes (+ fracture plane) | Yes | Extended strengths | Detailed analysis |
| LaRC | Yes (detailed) | Yes | Extended + misalignment | Research, compression |